Best Pizza Pans in 2023

Making pizza at home can sound like a daunting challenge, but it really isn’t. At least not when you’re using the best pizza pans on the market! Therefore, follow along for the best pizza pans so you can make the perfect pizza, regardless of your cooking skills.

Table of Contents

What kind of pan is best for pizza?

There are a few different pans best for cooking pizza. However, typically cast iron pizza pans are the most durable and versatile for cookin’ up any type of pizza. They’re heavy and require more cleaning than most pans, but this makes for easy cleanup and long-lasting kitchenware. Therefore, whether you’re trying to make a Chicago-style pizza or just a homemade pizza in general, these high-quality pans will do the trick!

Are pizza trays with holes better?

The million dollar question! Firstly, it’s good to know that pizza trays with holes are known as perforated pans. These holes allow heat distribution to go directly to the bottom of the pizza, which cooks it faster and also makes it more crispy. And we all love a fast cooking time!

There are a few pros to using a pizza pan with holes. For instance, it reduces the moisture in the pan (which in turn gives you a crispy pizza). In addition, the holes help the pizza cook more evenly. So, if you love crispy crust, I’d recommend a tray with holes.

However, there are also some cons to these types of pizza pans. For example, you need to watch your pizza carefully to make sure it doesn’t burn (especially the crust). Furthermore, these pans are often hard to clean unless they have a non-stick coating.

What is the best pan for a pizza party?

Maybe your child has a birthday coming up or it’s the end of the school year celebration. Either way, it’s imperative that you have at least one pizza pan ready on hand in case you need to entertain a lot of kids! There are a lot of pizza pans out there, which can make choosing the best one really hard.

Personally, if I know I’m going to be cooking for a lot of people, I’ll use my Wilton Recipe Right Pizza Pan. It’s great for large groups and cooks pizza’s just perfectly.

What are the benefits of using a pizza pan?

Whether you’re cooking a frozen pizza or made pizza dough from scratch, it’s really helpful to have a pizza pan on hand. Why? Well, let’s get into some of the benefits of using a pizza pan!

Firstly, pizza pans allow the pizza to cook more evenly. Therefore, when you take it out of the oven, you don’t need to worry about it being over or undercooked.

Secondly, they make for easy cleanup! Nothing is worse than making pizza from scratch and being left with a huge mess afterwards. Additionally, this is also why I recommend buying a dishwasher safe, nonstick pizza pan so you can have the most minimal cleanup possible. We all know hand washing a pizza pan is not fun!

Thirdly, a deep dish pizza pan is essential when making that Chicago-style deep dish pizza. A regular baking pan just isn’t going to cut it. Therefore, you need a pan that will allow you to create a thicker crust.

Lastly, pizza pans are heavy-duty. They’re made to withstand high temperatures and carry good heat retention. Not everyone has the option to have a full on pizza oven in their kitchen vicinity, so it’s imperative that you buy a simple pizza pan!

So, on the best pizza pans…

Now, let’s take a look at the best pizza pans on the market!

Best Overall: Wilton Premium Non-Stick Pizza Pan

This 14-inch pizza pan is perfect for cooking any type of pizza, homemade or store-bought. It’s completely oven-safe and dishwasher safe – and I love the smooth surface of the pan for optimal pizza baking.

Check Price

Best for Deep Dish: Nordic Ware Aluminum Pizza Pan

This pizza pan is created for commercial bakeware, so you know it will do the trick! It feature an encapsulated steel rim to prevent warping. However, this pan is not dishwasher safe – you must hand wash with soapy water only.

Check Price

For a Cast Iron Pan: Legend Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Made of pure steel construction and iron, this Legend skillet is a great cast-iron option. It has a nonstick finish and features large, heavy-duty side handles and deeper walls for extra protection. Plus, it also doubles as a griddle for things like omelets, fajitas, eggs, and more!

Check Price

Best for Perforated Pizza Pan: Calphalon Nonstick 16-Inch Pizza Pan

This perforated surface helps evenly cook pizza crust while preventing soggy bottoms. The pan is made of heavy-gauge steel that heats evenly. Moreover, this product has a lifetime manufacturer’s warranty!

Check Price

Most Versatility: Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan

Boasting a 16 inch diameter, this pizza pan is perfect for versatility. Not only will it perfectly cook your pizzas, it’s great for cooking breakfast foods such as pancakes or eggs. Therefore, this pan is a great choice for all around cookware!

Check Price

Best for Thin-Crust Pizza: Heritage Pizza Stone

This pizza stone is known for its fast pre-heat and speedy baking time. It’s great if you’re wanting to bake pizza with a thin, crisper crust. Plus, it’s a non-stick pan, so it provides easy cleanup. Yum!

Check Price

Best for Budget-Friendly: Chicago Metallic 14″ Pizza Crisper

Looking for a well-made pizza pan that is in your budget? This perforated pan offers superior air flow to create crispy crusts and even heating! Whether you’re cooking pizzas for a BBQ or a birthday party, this pan will do the trick!

perforated chicago crisper — Image via Bed Bath and Beyond

Check Price

For a Stainless Steel Pizza Pan: King Arthur Baking Pizza Pan

This pizza pan features a corrugated surface that improves airflow and produces a gold crust every time. It’s a mix of 65% recycled steel (for strength and durability) and aluminum (for great conductivity). Plus, it’s nonstick bakeware as the pan is coated with Americoat, so perfect for an easy release!